A minister of the New Methodist Church at Vaitele Fou has been sentenced to nine years in prison after being found guilty of raping an 18-year-old youth member of his church parish.
Reverand Petaia Setu was found guilty of rape plus three counts of unlawful sexual connection, and one count of indecent assault against the young woman.
Justice Fepuleai Ameperosa Roma handed down the 68 year old reverend’s sentence in the Supreme Court of Samoa on Wednesday afternoon, 14 October 2026.
The victim was between 16 and 18 years old when the offences occurred between late 2022 and late 2024. Reverand Petaia Setu waa 64 when the offences began.
The Court heard that the victim and her family were known to the pastor and his family.
She lived in Samoa with her grandparents who were senior members of the parish while her parents lived overseas. The victim was also a close friend of the reverand’s daughter.

In delivering the sentence, Justice Roma said Reverend Setu had abused the trust and authority placed in him as a religious leader.
“You occupied a position of trust and authority within the community,” Justice Roma said.
Justice Roma said the offending involved repeated sexual acts against the same victim over an extended period, eventually culminating in rape.
The Court heard that on three occasions, the pastor engaged in oral sexual contact with the victim without her consent, constituting unlawful sexual connection.
On another occasion, he sexually assaulted and raped her despite her attempts to resist.

Justice Roma said the victim did not consent to any of the acts established during the trial.
Now 20, the victim suffered significant emotional and psychological harm as a result of the offending.
According to Justice Roma, the victim later disclosed the incidents to her mother while visiting her overseas, eventually leading to the charges and prosecution.

Justice Roma said the victim’s impact statement described the ongoing trauma she experienced when recalling the events.
“She reports that revisiting the events causes her to relive the trauma,” Justice Roma said.
The Court identified several aggravating factors, including the victim’s young age, the 48-year age difference between the victim and the pastor, the repeated nature of the offending, and the abuse of his position as her pastor.

Justice Roma also noted that the offences occurred at the pastor’s residence, where the young woman, as a member of his church, was entitled to feel safe.
“The offending was repeated and occurred in circumstances where you occupied a position of trust and authority, thereby aggravating its seriousness,” Justice Roma said.

Justice Roma said people in positions of religious leadership were expected to act in a manner consistent with the trust placed in them by their communities.
“Where that trust is abused in the commission of serious sexual offending, the need for the court’s response to mark the offending and deter similar conduct is correspondingly heightened,” Justice Roma said.

In considering the pastor’s personal circumstances, the Court took into account his age of 68, his previous good character, his status as a first offender, and his lengthy service to the church and community.
Justice Roma also considered numerous character references submitted by family members, church members, fellow ministers, religious organisations, and community leaders.

The references described him as a devoted father, counsellor, minister, spiritual leader, and religious colleague.
However, Justice Roma emphasised that the references could not diminish the seriousness of the offending or the harm suffered by the victim.
“They rightly acknowledge that the references cannot diminish the gravity of the offending or its consequences for the victim,” Justice Roma said.

The Court adopted a starting point of 11 years’ imprisonment, taking into account the repeated offences and the abuse of the pastor’s position of trust and authority.
Justice Roma then deducted two years from the starting point, allowing 12 months for the pastor’s personal circumstances, previous good character and first-offender status, and a further 12 months for his longstanding service to his family, church and community.

“The resulting end sentence is therefore nine years in prison,” Justice Roma said.
Justice Roma said the sentence reflected the repeated nature of the offending, the abuse of trust, the harm caused to the victim, and the need for accountability and deterrence.
Justice Roma ordered that all sentences be served concurrently, meaning they will run at the same time, subject to any applicable adjustment for time already spent in custody.

- Man Sentenced to Community Service for Indecent Act Against Young Relative Under His Care - November 13, 2026
- Opposition Leader Pleads Not Guilty to Defamation Charges - November 12, 2026
- Woman Found Dead in her Apia Apartment: Police say “It’s too early to ask” about the investigation - November 3, 2026














