Home News Local Court: “Free and Fair Elections are the Bedrock of Democratic Governance”

Court: “Free and Fair Elections are the Bedrock of Democratic Governance”

0
1266

In a first for Samoa, the Supreme Court found 26 of 51 respondents, guilty of contempt of court while clearing others whom the Court believed were misled into believing the hearing had been cancelled. The judgement sent a strong warning that those who interfere with election petition proceedings or ignore Court summonses, are undermining Samoa’s democracy.

In a judgment released today, Chief Justice Satiu Simativa Perese and Justice Leiataualesa Daryl Clarke said:

“Free and fair elections are the bedrock of democratic governance. They signal the true will of the electors and are not outcomes that may be tainted by corruption.”

Of the 26 respondents found guilty, 18 face fines of $500 tala while 8 were fined $200 tala, all payable by 12th of August 2026. There were 23 respondents cleared after the Court accepted they had travelled to the Courthouse but relied on false information that the proceedings had been withdrawn. One respondent was never served and did not appear, while one respondent had since passed away.

The Court said this time it would only hand down fines, setting them at $500 and $200. “Having considered these proceedings carefully, the Court will impose financial penalties only. Penalties are imposed in two categories. First, a fine of $500.00 is reserved for those respondents whose evidence was contrived or misleading, or whose deliberate non-attendance at Court was calculated.

The $200.00 tala fine was “reserved for those respondents who the Court found truthful and genuine but their non-attendance at Court was nevertheless deliberate dis-obeyance of the Court summons at the lower end of the spectrum of seriousness.”

The Court express concerns about witness credibility and excuses such as forgettin to turn up, or that they were told to go home because the case between Hon Toelupe Pou Onesemo and Tuiloma Lance Lameko had been withdrawn – ua mae’a ona soalaupule.

“The Court found the evidence of a number of respondents to be insincere, rehearsed and in several instances, wholly lacking in credibility,” the judgement read.

“One theme in the evidence was the assertion by some witnesses that they had simply “forgotten” to attend Court, despite having been served only two or three days beforehand and despite clear warnings from police officers serving the summons as to the importance of their attendance, and the potential consequences of failing to appear..”

“One carpenter claimed he “forgot” and went to work as usual. One respondent said he went to breakfast at Pinati’s and, having read on Facebook that the matter had been withdrawn, decided not to appear. These explanations, among many others were unconvincing.”

The Court described the Falealili 1 election petition as “highly divisive,” saying the evidence revealed “allegedly unlawful steps to derail the petition hearings.”

The judges thanked those witnesses who came forward and gave honest evidence, saying their testimony helped the Court understand “the extent of those efforts.”

The Court said the evidence raised “allegations of potential criminal contempt” involving Tuiloma Sagaga Failala Pu’a, Seufaleupolu Apelila and former Deputy Prime Minister Toelupe Poumulinuku Onesemo stating that this “warranted further investigation.”

However the decision also conceded that the three did not have the opportunity to reply to the allegations made by the respondents against them.

Chief Justice Satiu and Justice Leiataualesa Daryl Clarke said Court orders must be obeyed if public confidence in elections and the justice system is to be maintained.

The judgment concluded that attempts to interfere with witnesses or frustrate election petitions will be treated by the Court as a serious threat to Samoa’s democratic process.

Alofa Grace

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here